Category: 42 Word Retrospectives

Tintin: The Red Sea Sharks

Tintin: The Red Sea Sharks

by Hergé (Tintin Magazine, 1956-1958)

English Edition trans. Leslie Lonsdale-Cooper (Methuen, 1960)

Book cover: “Tintin: The Red Sea Sharks” by Hergé (Tintin Magazine, 1956-1958); English Edition trans. Leslie Lonsdale-Cooper (Methuen, 1960)

A curious volume. Hergé oscillates between depicting Tintin in the early adventuring style, condemning the modern slave trade (perhaps the most serious theme in the entire Tintin canon), and revelling in a broad-cast comedy of slapstick. These threads remain disparate and unwoven.

Doctor Who: The Gunfighters

Doctor Who: The Gunfighters

by Donald Cotton (Target, 1985); audiobook read by Shane Rimmer (BBC, 2013)

Book cover: “Doctor Who: The Gunfighters” by Donald Cotton (Target, 1985); audiobook read by Shane Rimmer (BBC, 2013)

As daring an experiment as Cotton’s original script (and even more so in audiobook form with Rimmer’s total commitment to cowboy drawl). Superbly witty on a line-by-line level, and unlike so much of the Doctor Who canon the prose has independent merit.

Douglas Adams’s Starship Titanic

Douglas Adams’s Starship Titanic

by Terry Jones (Pan, 1997)

audiobook read by Bill Nighy (Pan, 2023)

Book cover: “Douglas Adams’s Starship Titanic” by Terry Jones (Pan, 1997); audiobook read by Bill Nighy (Pan, 2023)

Given only a three-week deadline, Jones produced a passable Adams pastiche. Starship Titanic has its moments but more often serves to highlight, through laboured contrast, the finesses that Adams himself sweated blood over in pulling off his particular brand of freewheeling facetiousness.

The Elephant Who Liked to Smash Small Cars

The Elephant Who Liked to Smash Small Cars

by Jean Merrill; ill. Ronni Solbert

(The New York Review Children’s Collection, 2015) [First published by Pantheon Books, 1967]

Book cover: “The Elephant Who Liked to Smash Small Cars” by Jean Merrill; ill. Ronni Solbert (The New York Review Children’s Collection, 2015) [First published by Pantheon Books, 1967]

A simple, whimsical picture book that revels in its tale of comeuppance. The elephant, gleeful smasher of cars, changes his ways after receiving a taste of his own medicine. Solbert’s crayon illustrations evoke the spirit of preschool paintings or early computer games.

Death-Watch

Death-Watch

by John Dickson Carr (Harper & Bros., 1935)

audiobook read by Jonathan Keeble (Oakhill, 2019)

Book cover: “Death-Watch” by John Dickson Carr (Harper & Bros., 1935); audiobook read by Jonathan Keeble (Oakhill, 2019)

Carr obviously spent a long time working out not only how the murder could have occurred but also how those involved would likely have acted and how events might be misconstrued. Despite Gideon Fell’s rumbustious presence, it’s all rather scientific and dry.

Jumping Jenny

Jumping Jenny

by Anthony Berkeley (Hodder & Stoughton, 1933)

audiobook read by Seán Barrett (Soundings, 2022)

Book cover: “Jumping Jenny” by Anthony Berkeley (Hodder & Stoughton, 1933); audiobook read by Seán Barrett (Soundings, 2022)

Musing upon what looks to be a house-party suicide, prominent amateur detective Roger Sheringham, present from the outset, indulges one fancy too many and accidentally implicates himself as prime suspect in a murder! A droll study in dramatic irony and narrative doctoring.

Thirteen Guests

Thirteen Guests

by J. Jefferson Farjeon (Collins, 1936)

audiobook read by David Thorpe (Soundings, 2020)

Book cover: “Thirteen Guests” by J. Jefferson Farjeon (Collins, 1936); audiobook read by David Thorpe (Soundings, 2020)

A relatively simple murder mystery obfuscated through excessive characterisation of players who are dropped without a second thought. Short and accessible but holds back its detective (the energetic, straight-shooting Inspector Kendall) until the race is more than half run. Perfunctory twist ending.

Prelude to Foundation

Prelude to Foundation

by Isaac Asimov (Doubleday, 1988)

audiobook read by William Hope (HarperVoyager, 2023)

Book cover: “Prelude to Foundation” by Isaac Asimov (Doubleday, 1988); audiobook read by William Hope (HarperVoyager, 2023)

Self-indulgent. Asimov trades on his name more than his ideas, with middling prose and revelatory twists that survive only through clumsy concealment beneath a glut of character-voiced speculation as to how future society might function. Hope’s Seldon accent is a brave choice.

Derelict Space Sheep