Category: 42 Word Retrospectives

Hamlet, Revenge!

Hamlet, Revenge!

by Michael Innes (Gollancz, 1937); audiobook read by Matt Addis (2015)

Book cover: “Hamlet, Revenge!” by Michael Innes (Gollancz, 1937); audiobook read by Matt Addis (2015)

Poetic and engaging. A clever, complicated mystery, rendered slightly unsatisfying by the lengthy preamble and the shifting narrative perspective. Innes has everything planned out but cannot contrive for Appleby to solve the case alone (or even with the help of Giles Gott).

Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!

Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!

dir. Russ Meyer (1965)

Film poster: “Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!” dir. Russ Meyer (1965)

Affected and stilted exploitation film. The three desperados display uninhibited busts and unmotivated aggression against all and sundry (themselves included). The relentless musical backdrop affords a sense of silent comedy or spoof, though whatever humour Meyer was aiming for fails to materialise.

Dark Thoughts at Noon

Dark Thoughts at Noon

by Timothy Zahn (Analog, December 1982)

Magazine cover: Analog, December 1982; review of: “Dark Thoughts at Noon” by Timothy Zahn

A diverting enough novelette, more workmanlike than mesmerising. Zahn has a knack for layering a speculative development onto regular society and then postulating pitfalls and repercussions. In this instance, though, the telepathic protagonist has little say in the outcome of his misadventure.

The Thirteen Problems

The Thirteen Problems

by Agatha Christie (Collins Crime Club, 1932)

audiobook read by Juliet Stevenson (HarperCollins, 2022)

Book cover: “The Thirteen Problems” by Agatha Christie (Collins Crime Club, 1932); audiobook read by Juliet Stevenson (HarperCollins, 2022)

This first collection of mysteries shows Miss Marple well-suited to the short form. Some of the stories are better than others, some crimes more ingenious, but Christie usually plants enough clues to have the reader exclaim, “Oh, of course!” at the end.

Making History

Making History

by Stephen Fry (Hutchinson, 1996)

audiobook ready by Stephen Fry and Richard E. Grant (Penguin, 2021)

Book cover: “Making History” by Stephen Fry (Hutchinson, 1996); audiobook ready by Stephen Fry and Richard E. Grant (Penguin, 2021)

A cleverly conceived, assiduously researched but poorly paced take on the classic ‘Kill Hitler’ time alteration tale. Fry writes in a conversational style and displays an undoubted gift for off-the-cuff storytelling. As a novelist, however, his expressiveness manifests too often as waffle.

No Wind of Blame

No Wind of Blame

by Georgette Heyer (Hodder & Stoughton, 1939)

audiobook read by Ulli Birvé (Bolinda, 2014)

Book cover: “No Wind of Blame” by Georgette Heyer (Hodder & Stoughton, 1939); audiobook read by Ulli Birvé (Bolinda, 2014)

The (supposedly ingenious) murder doesn’t occur until Heyer has spent one third of the book establishing a turgid and disagreeable dramatis personae. Inspector Hemmingway appears only three fifths of the way through and, though a lively protagonist, cannot stem the stultifying tide.

Death at Victoria Dock

Death at Victoria Dock

by Kerry Greenwood (Poisoned Pen Press, 1992)

audiobook read by Stephanie Daniel (ABC, 2011)

Book cover: “Death at Victoria Dock” by Kerry Greenwood (Poisoned Pen Press, 1992); audiobook read by Stephanie Daniel (ABC, 2011)

Stephanie Daniel’s audiobook reading lends vivid personality to all the characters; Greenwood’s depiction of interbellum Melbourne society suggests considerable research; yet Phryne herself has become more goddess than investigator. She is adored and feared to the extent of encountering too little resistance.

Mortimer’s Cross

Mortimer’s Cross

by Joan Aiken (Harper & Row, 1983)

audiobook read by Judy Bennett (Bolinda, 2015) [as part of the 3-in-1 collection ‘Mortimer’s Cross’]

Book covers: “Mortimer’s Cross” by Joan Aiken (Harper & Row, 1983); audiobook read by Judy Bennett (Bolinda, 2015) [as part of the 3-in-1 collection ‘Mortimer’s Cross’]

A lively middle-grade adventure, Dahl-like in tone but with a more adult vocabulary suggestive of Mortimer’s origins (being read aloud on Jackanory). Bennett’s enthusiastically British- and Welsh-accented audiobook narration does capture the spirit, but it’s a shame to forego Quentin Blake’s illustrations.

The Weirdstone of Brisingamen

The Weirdstone of Brisingamen

by Alan Garner (William Collins, 1960)

audiobook read by Philip Madoc (Naxos, 2007)

Book cover: “The Weirdstone of Brisingamen” by Alan Garner (William Collins, 1960); audiobook read by Philip Madoc (Naxos, 2007)

A dour quest fantasy for children, lent solemnity (if not consequence) by its very real sense of landscape—rural Cheshire—and in the audiobook by Philip Madoc’s Welsh inflections and portentous, almost reverent reading. Though trials are faced, nothing much actually happens.

Derelict Space Sheep